Seller Impersonation Fraud Now Reaches 59% of Title Firms

A fake owner tries to sell a property that belongs to someone else, and the scheme can look convincing until the money is gone. New industry data shows this crime, known as seller impersonation fraud, is no longer rare. It is now something most title companies expect to see.
What the new study found
The American Land Title Association (ALTA) released its 2026 Critical Issues Study on September 14. HousingWire reports that 59% of title firms had at least one seller impersonation attempt in the prior calendar year. In ALTA's 2024 survey, that figure was 28%.
Other numbers in the study point the same way:
- The share of firms reporting an attempt in the month before the survey rose from 19% to 45%.
- Firms reporting three or more attempts in a single month rose from 4% to 23%.
- Among firms that saw an attempt, one in four also reported a paid claim, and among those that disclosed an average claim cost, half said it exceeded $100,000.
The survey covered 245 title insurance professionals across 40 states, the District of Columbia and the U.S. Virgin Islands, according to a summary of the findings. The figures include both successful and unsuccessful attempts.
How the scam works
Seller impersonation fraud happens when a criminal poses as the legitimate owner of a property and tries to sell it. Property records are public, so a criminal can look up who owns a home or parcel and build a false identity around it.
ALTA's survey, as reported by Realtor.com and Yahoo, found that fraudsters often arrive well prepared:
- 87% of respondents said spoofed contact information was at least somewhat common.
- 70% reported criminals using the owner's birth date.
- 60% cited knowledge of the owner's financial information.
- 55% cited Social Security numbers.
ALTA also warns that fraudsters may use an actual owner's identifying information and even legitimate notary credentials without the notary's knowledge.
Common red flags
Texas officials have published plain-language warning signs. The Texas Real Estate Commission and the Texas Land Title Association (TLTA) describe prime targets as vacant land and investment property, such as vacation homes, second homes and rentals. Another clue is a tax mailing address that differs from the owner's address.
Their red flags include a seller who:
- Wants a quick sale or a cash sale.
- Lists the property below market value.
- Communicates only by email or text and avoids meeting in person.
- Has a phone area code that is unrecognizable or foreign.
The Texas Department of Insurance adds that a seller who doesn't show up for closing, asks to sign electronically, or wants to bring their own notary deserves extra scrutiny.
What it means in Texas
Texas has been closely tied to this issue. TLTA formed a Seller Impersonation Fraud Task Force and partnered with the Texas Real Estate Commission and Texas REALTORS® to educate real estate professionals.
The Texas Department of Insurance advises buyers to visit a property in person and buy title insurance. It also suggests asking the agent to use a trusted in-person notary at closing. It recommends reporting fraud to the Texas Attorney General, the Federal Trade Commission and local police.
A TLTA paper on property fraud notes that these schemes mostly target unimproved or vacant land where the owner is absent. It says fraudsters usually push for a remote transaction so they never appear at the title company. The same paper notes that a forged deed does not actually transfer an owner's rights, but untangling one can still be costly and stressful. Anyone facing a suspected fraudulent deed should speak with a real estate attorney.
Where notaries fit in
Notaries are one safeguard among several. ALTA found that 94% of firms use multiple tools to detect fraud. They rated an average of 5.3 tools as helpful, including identity verification systems, direct seller contact, multifactor authentication, approved notaries and knowledge-based authentication. Title firms most often catch the fraud during the clearance or curative stage, before closing.
The National Notary Association (NNA) weighed in this week as well. Its new white paper, More Than a Method, compares the four methods a notary may now use to perform a notarial act. The paper does not name a best method. It argues that the assurances behind the act matter most, whether it is done on paper, electronically, or remotely online.
In practice, a notary's role is to verify that the signer is who they claim to be. Every signer needs a valid, unexpired government-issued photo ID, and documents should stay unsigned until the notary is present. A notary can't confirm that a person owns a property, so title companies and agents still do that work. Notaries also keep a journal of each act, which creates a record that can matter if a transaction is questioned. Journal rules differ by state, and state-law notary journals are available for all 50 states and DC.
Practical takeaways
Property owners, especially those with vacant land, rentals or second homes, can check their county's property records now and then. Many counties offer free alerts when a document is recorded under an owner's name. Ask your county clerk what is available.
Sellers and buyers can insist on working with a licensed title company, and can be wary when a seller resists meeting in person or video-calling.
Agents and title teams can verify identity through more than one channel and compare IDs against recorded documents. They should treat urgency as a signal to slow down.
Signers who prefer an in-person signing can use in-office notarization in downtown Dallas or request a mobile notary. Same-day and after-hours appointments can be requested and depend on notary availability. For questions about your own property or documents, consult a real estate attorney.
The data points to a simple lesson. Fraudsters are betting that no one will look closely, and many title firms are now building the habit of looking closely at every file.
This post is general information, not legal advice. Notary rules differ from state to state; for advice about your own documents or situation, talk with an attorney.
Closing on a home in Dallas–Fort Worth?
Our signing agents meet borrowers at home, at work or in our downtown Dallas office for purchases, refinances, HELOCs and seller packages. Bring valid, unexpired photo ID and leave your documents unsigned until we're together.
The monthly Uptown Notary newsletter
Once a month, every post in one email: industry news, notary know-how and Uptown Notary announcements. No spam, unsubscribe any time.